Saturday, February 07, 2026

Vadney (p. 393)


Catherine Vadney conveyed Blackacre “to herself and her son Peter.”

Her intention was to create a Joint Tenancy between herself and Peter.

 She dies with a will that has a residuary clause providing that any property not specifically devised by her will would be shared equally by all of her surviving children (Peter and his 3 siblings).

Did the deed create a Joint Tenancy between Catherine and Peter (thus Peter as the survivor takes all), or a Tenancy in Common in which case Catherine’s one-half share would pass under the will to all the children equally?
 
What is the problem with this deed?


p. 394 Note 2—should an attorney be liable for malpractice if he fails “to carry out clear instructions by the client as to a desired legal effect" Should my doctor be liable for medical malpractice if I go under the knife to have my right leg amputated and he mistakenly amputates my healthy left leg?